Alpha Aviation Ltd v Kevin Peter Turnquest

JurisdictionBahamas
CourtSupreme Court (Bahamas)
JudgeMadam Justice Carla D. Card-Stubbs
Judgment Date14 December 2022
Docket Number2021/CLE/gen/00354
Between
Alpha Aviation Limited
Plaintiff
and
Kevin Peter Turnquest
First Defendant

and

Randy Larry Butler
Second Defendant

and

Larona Butler
Third Defendant
Before:

The Honourable Madam Justice Carla D. Card-Stubbs

2021/CLE/gen/00354

IN THE SUPREME COURT

Common Law & Equity Division

Conspiracy to Defraud — Deed of Release — Loss of Mortgage Collateral — Whether the Defendants agreed to injure the Plaintiff

Director's Fiduciary Duties — Companies Act — Duty of Care — Whether Breach of Duty by executing a Deed of Release

Whether Plaintiff Company suffered a loss

There is in civil law, lawful means conspiracy and unlawful means conspiracy. The starting point for each is whether there was a concerted action and agreement between the Defendants with a predominant purpose to cause damage to the claimant (lawful means conspiracy/conspiracy by lawful means) or whether there was a concerted action and agreement between the Defendants with an intention to injure the Plaintiff (unlawful means conspiracy/conspiracy by unlawful means). In this case, the Plaintiff failed to prove an agreement between the Defendants and therefore the conspiracy claim failed. However, having regard to the sole acts of the director in this case, he is liable for breach of fiduciary duty. No damages are recoverable where the breach of duty does not cause a measurable loss.

Appearances:

Michael Scott KC & Marnique Knowles of Counsel for the Plaintiff; Robert Adams KC & Samuel Brown of Counsel for the First Defendant; Michael Horton for the Second & Third Defendants

Introduction
1

This is a suit brought by the Plaintiff alleging a conspiracy by the First, Second and Third Defendants to defraud the Plaintiff. The Plaintiff also alleges a breach of a fiduciary duty by the First Defendant.

2

For the reasons that follow, this Court holds (1) that the Plaintiff has not proven a conspiracy to defraud the Plaintiff, (2) that the First Defendant is in breach of a fiduciary duty and a statutory duty to exercise care, diligence and skill and (3) that the Plaintiff has suffered no measurable loss as a result of that breach.

Background
3

It is the Plaintiff's case that the First, Second and Third Defendant conspired to defraud it of the outstanding balance owed under a mortgage agreement and that the First Defendant as Manager and Director of the Plaintiff breached his fiduciary duty to the Plaintiff by executing a Deed of Release in relation to the said mortgage without first securing payment of the money owing under the mortgage.

4

The Plaintiff's action as laid out in its Specially-Indorsed Writ of Summons is for:

  • i. Damages;

  • ii. A Declaration that the Plaintiff holds the legal title to the Property by virtue of the Mortgage and Further Charge;

  • iii. A Declaration that the Defendants hold the sum of $220,313,43 and/or all assets representing such sums, on constructive or resulting trust for the Plaintiff;

  • iv. Compensation for breach of director's duties by the First Defendant;

  • v. Interest pursuant to the Supreme Court Act or in equity

  • vi. Further or other relief; and

  • vii. Costs

5

The following facts are agreed among the parties.

  • i. The Plaintiff is a company incorporated in The Commonwealth of The Bahamas.

  • ii. On January 7, 2005, the Plaintiff lent the sum of $279,000.00 “Mortgage” to the Second and Third Defendants which was to be repaid at a rate of 4% per annum over 20 years and secured by a mortgage over property described as Lot 5 Block 13 Winton Heights Estate subdivision “ Winton Property.”

  • iii. On March 28, 2007, the Plaintiff lent a further sum of $120,000.00 to the First and Second Defendants which was referred to as a Further Charge over the property “ Further Charge”.

  • iv. The Plaintiff was the mortgagee of the Winton Property.

  • v. The Second and Third Defendants were the mortgagors of the Winton Property.

  • vi. On December 17, 2008, the Second and Third Defendants executed a conveyance of the fee simple of the Winton Property to Mr. & Mrs. Smith by way of sale.

  • vii. The First, Second and Third Defendants executed a Deed of Release dated March 15, 2017.

  • viii. Mr. Fredrick Kaiser was at all material times the beneficial owner of the Plaintiff.

  • ix. The First Defendant was a Director and Manager of the Plaintiff from about November 1998 to May 2017.

  • x. The First Defendant was a Manager and Director of the Plaintiff at the time that the loans under the Mortgage and Further Charge were made and at the time that the Deed of Release was executed.

6

The following allegations are disputed and go to the matters in issue.

DISPUTED FACTS – PLAINTIFF'S ALLEGATIONS
  • i. The Plaintiff alleges that the Second and Third Defendants conspired to defraud the Plaintiff by purporting to convey the Winton property without the knowledge or consent of the Plaintiff. The Plaintiff alleges that the conveyance did not reflect a mortgage in favour of the Plaintiff and that the proceeds of sale were not used to redeem the mortgage.

  • ii. The Plaintiff alleges that at the time of the execution of the Deed of Release, there was a significant sum of money owing under the mortgage. The Plaintiff alleges that the First, Second and Third Defendants knew that at the time of the execution of the Deed of Release there was a significant sum of money owing under the mortgage and that they conspired to defraud the Plaintiff.

  • iii. The Plaintiff alleges that the First Defendant breached his duty as a Director.

DISPUTED FACTS – DEFENCE OF FIRST DEFENDANT
  • i. The First Defendant filed an Amended Defence on May 9, 2022. The First Defendant denies the allegations of conspiracy to defraud and of breach of duty as a director.

  • ii. The First Defendant alleges that the mortgage and further charge were made on the instructions of Mr. Kaiser. They were to be made on the condition that they were secured by way of mortgage over the Winton Property.

  • iii. The First Defendant alleges that he was informed by the Second Defendant in 2012 that the Winton Property had been sold to Mr. & Mrs. Smith and that the proceeds of sale would be used to pay off a mortgage on their new home. The First Defendant alleges that the Second Defendant also informed him that the Second Defendant and the Third Defendant would execute a mortgage over the new home as security for the money due and payable under the previous mortgage and further charge of the Winton Property, viz that they had agreed to substitute the security.

  • iv. The First Defendant alleges that thereafter, also in 2012, he was contacted by the lawyers for the mortgagee Mr. & Mrs. Smith, purchasers of the Winton property. The lawyer also acted for the Purchasers' mortgagor. The lawyer requested that the Plaintiff execute a Deed of Release. The First Defendant alleges that he denied the request but executed the Deed in 2017 following an in-person meeting with Mr. Kaiser who concurred to the execution of the Deed of Release.

  • v. The First Defendant also alleges that he agreed to the request to execute the Deed of Release because (1) he was advised that the validity of the mortgage could be challenged since the Plaintiff Company did not have exchange control approval to make the loans and obtain security, (2) the Second Defendant and the Third Defendant were repaying the loans as agreed, (3) the Second Defendant and the Third Defendant had agreed to secure the debt by way of mortgage over the new home and (4) Mr. Kaiser concurred.

DISPUTED FACTS – DEFENCE OF SECOND AND THIRD DEFENDANTS
  • I. The Second Defendant and Third Defendant filed a Defence on May 12, 2021. The Second Defendant and Third Defendant deny the allegations of conspiracy to defraud.

  • II. The Second Defendant and Third Defendant allege that the Winton property was sold with the knowledge and approval of the Plaintiff, who introduced the Purchaser to them. This is a reference to the First Defendant who the Second Defendant and Third Defendant claim acted on the Plaintiff's behalf.

  • III. The Second Defendant and Third Defendant allege that they were called upon years after the sale transaction to sign the Deed of Release. They also allege that they never received the proceeds of sale of the Winton Property.

7

ISSUES

The broad issues before this Court are:

  • a. Whether the First, Second and Third Defendants conspired to defraud the Plaintiff?

  • b. Whether the First Defendant breached his fiduciary duty to the Plaintiff by executing a Deed of Release?

  • c. Whether the Plaintiff suffered any loss as a result of a breach attributable to either the First, Second or Third Defendant and, if so, what is the measurement of that loss?

8

ISSUE 1 – CONSPIRACY TO DEFRAUD

Whether the First, Second and Third Defendants conspired to defraud the Plaintiff?

Submissions of the parties
9

The Plaintiff alleges that the Second and Third Defendants purported to convey the Winton property without the Plaintiff's permission, that the conveyance to the Smiths did not reflect the Plaintiff's mortgage, that the sale proceeds were not used to redeem the mortgage and further charge and that the Defendants executed the Deed of Release thus extinguishing the Plaintiff's security. The Plaintiff submits that the Defendants by the signing of the Deed of Release must have had a meeting of the minds with the clear intention of causing damage and did so by defrauding the Plaintiff since they knew that the debt was outstanding and did not take steps to pay it off. The Plaintiff submits that they caused the Plaintiff financial loss in the amount outstanding under the mortgage and further charge.

10

The Plaintiff submitted that in determining the agreement necessary for conspiracy, that such an agreement may be formal, informal, express or tacit and may be inferred per Kuwait Oil Tanker Co SAK v Al Bader [2000] 2 All ER (Comm) 271 and that there must be a meeting of the minds per Crofter Hand Woven Harris Tweed Co Ltd v...

Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI

Get Started for Free

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex